Download PDF by Rodney Stark: Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic

By Rodney Stark

ISBN-10: 1599474999

ISBN-13: 9781599474991

As we know and as lots of our good tested textbooks have argued for many years, the Inquisition was once some of the most scary and bloody chapters in Western background, Pope Pius XII was once anti-Semitic and rightfully known as “Hitler’s Pope,” the darkish a long time have been a stunting of the growth of information to be redeemed purely through the secular spirit of the Enlightenment, and the spiritual Crusades have been an early instance of the rapacious Western thirst for riches and gear. yet what if those lengthy held ideals have been all wrong?
during this lovely, robust, and finally persuasive ebook, Rodney Stark, probably the most very hot sociologists of faith and bestselling writer of The upward push of Christianity (HarperSanFrancisco 1997) argues that a few of our such a lot firmly held rules approximately background, rules that paint the Catholic Church the least bit optimistic gentle are, in reality, fiction. Why have we held those wrongheaded principles so strongly and for thus lengthy? And if our ideals are mistaken, what, actually, is the truth?
In every one bankruptcy, Stark takes on a well-established anti-Catholic fantasy, offers a desirable background of ways each one fantasy turned the traditional knowledge, and provides a startling photograph of the genuine fact. For example,

  • Instead of the Spanish Inquisition being an anomaly of torture and homicide of blameless humans persecuted for “imaginary” crimes reminiscent of witchcraft and blasphemy, Stark argues that not just did the Spanish Inquisition spill little or no blood, however it was once a huge strength in help of moderation and justice.
  • Instead of Pope Pius XII being apathetic or maybe beneficial to the Nazi move, resembling to advantage the identify, “Hitler’s Pope,” Stark exhibits that the crusade to hyperlink Pope Pius XII to Hitler was once initiated through the Soviet Union, most likely in hopes of neutralizing the Vatican in post-World struggle II affairs. Pope Pius XII used to be broadly praised for his lively and dedicated efforts to saving Jewish lives throughout the war.
  • Instead of the darkish a while being understood as a millennium of lack of understanding and backwardness encouraged by means of the Catholic Church’s energy, Stark argues that the total suggestion of the “Dark a long time” used to be an act of satisfaction perpetuated by way of anti-religious intellectuals who have been decided to assert that theirs was once the period of “Enlightenment.”

In the top, readers won't in basic terms have a extra exact background of the Catholic Church, they're going to come to appreciate why it turned unfairly maligned for therefore lengthy. Bearing fake Witness is a compelling and sobering account of ways egotism and beliefs frequently interact to provide us a fake truth.    

Show description

Read Online or Download Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History PDF

Similar history & culture books

Download e-book for kindle: Keeping the U.S. Computer Industry Competitive: Defining the by National Research Council, Computer Science and

This e-book warns that protecting U. S. preeminence in computing before everything of the subsequent century would require long term making plans, management, and collective will that can not be attained with a business-as-usual procedure through or govt. This consensus emerged from a colloquium of best executives from the U.

Download e-book for iPad: Intelligence and Security Informatics: IEEE ISI 2008 by Christopher C. Yang, Hsinchun Chen, Michael Chau, Kuiyu

This e-book constitutes the refereed complaints of the 3 foreign workshops PAISI 2008, PACCF 2008, and SOCO 2008, held as satellite tv for pc occasions of the IEEE foreign convention on Intelligence and safety Informatics, ISI 2008, in Taipei, Taiwan, in June 2008. The fifty five revised complete papers offered have been conscientiously reviewed and chosen from the shows on the workshops.

Karen Southwick's High Noon: The Inside Story of Scott McNealy and the Rise of PDF

In 1982, a bit upstart named solar used to be making waves within the high-tech with its groundbreaking computer know-how, at the same time early rivals disregarded the corporate as now not worthy wasting sleep over. on the grounds that then, sunlight Microsystems has develop into an impressive presence within the undefined, making its personal ideas and taking no prisoners, and is at the moment poised to arrive the top element of its ascendancy--the problem of Microsoft's dominance over the way forward for computing.

Looking Back and Going Forward in IT - download pdf or read online

This booklet areas IT in standpoint through tracing its improvement via time, overlaying its origins in company, the large growth of the function of IT on the finish of the 20 th century, the expansion of the net, and the successes and screw ups of businesses focused on this improvement. regardless of its ubiquity within the glossy global, the writer highlights that effective use of IT by way of companies can in simple terms be won by means of an outstanding knowing of its potentials and pitfalls, highlighting how its knowledgeable use in perform is vital for corporations to prevail.

Additional resources for Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History

Example text

But several years ago, it started all over again with a spate of new books. Even though these books display remarkable ignorance as well as self-indulgence, they mostly received very positive reviews in the popular press and sold very well, thus stimulating and justifying a great deal of “informed” anti-Catholicism. As so often happens, many qualified historians have written scathing reviews that reveal the extreme biases and scholarly incompetence of these authors,84 but these reviews have not been widely circulated.

Sometimes I have done basic research needed to overturn one of these spurious anti-Catholic claims, and in those cases I document my findings so fully that anyone can check them. But, in most instances, I am simply reporting the prevailing view among qualified experts. 12 I have undertaken to make the work of these fine scholars widely available, taking care to cite and fully acknowledge their work—short biographies of major contributors will be presented in each chapter. Finally, I am not a Roman Catholic, and I did not write this book in defense of the Church.

Nor did anyone challenge the celebrated Jewish historian Heinrich Hirsh Graetz when he asserted, “Judaism ever strove towards the light, whilst monastic Christianity remained in darkness. ”63 It is difficult to know how anyone, even the most bitter anti-Catholic, could truly have believed any of this! By itself, the biography of Moses Maimonides (1135–1204) makes a travesty of all these claims. In 1148, the Maimonides family pretended to convert to Islam when the Jews of Córdoba were told to become Muslims or leave, upon pain of death.

Download PDF sample

Bearing False Witness: Debunking Centuries of Anti-Catholic History by Rodney Stark

by William

Rated 4.22 of 5 – based on 43 votes